TOL — —
Loading…
— —
PREV CLOSE — OPEN — DAY RANGE —
Analyzing 0%
MASTER — —
ESEN VERDICT
Analyzing…
Horizon6–12M
Confidence—
Data coverage—
ESEN Ranks Forecast News Intelligence Fundamentals ESEN Deep Analysis Screener
I'll provide a comprehensive institutional analysis of Toll Brothers (TOL) using the live data provided. Let me first search for current analyst price targets to complete the analysis. Based on the live data and analyst research, here is my institutional analysis:
TOLL BROTHERS INC (TOL) – INSTITUTIONAL EQUITY RESEARCH
Analysis Date: July 30, 2026 | Current Price: $150.20 | Market Cap: $14.35B
MASTER SCORING TABLE
Metric Grade Score Evidence Horizon
FINAL ESEN MASTER SCORE B+ 78 Compelling valuation with moderate growth offset by macro headwinds and EPS contraction 6-12M
SA Quality/Value Composite A- 82 P/E 10.66x with dividend yield 69bp; strong absolute valuation vs. luxury residential sector; forward P/E 11.08x suggests modest re-rating headroom 6-12M
Zacks Earnings Momentum C+ 62 EPS growth -1.97% YoY despite 3.62% revenue growth; margin pressure and order flow uncertainty offset topline stability 1-3M
Institutional & Smart Money Flow B 75 Post-earnings raises from Wells Fargo, UBS; -3.08% intraday pullback suggests profit-taking after 22.2% YTD rally; analyst consensus "Buy" (29 analysts) with $164.44 avg target 1-3M
Growth Sustainability & Moat C 65 Revenue growth +3.62% YoY constrained vs. sector; macro uncertainty on housing demand; luxury segment resilient but cyclical; limited pricing power in softer environment 6-12M
Valuation & Safety (Pre-Penalty) A 86 P/E 10.66x vs. historical mean 15-18x; beta 1.35x implies 35% volatility premium; dividend coverage stable; balance sheet flags: weak_balance=False suggests adequate liquidity 6-12M
Penalty Overlay -8 pts -8 EPS contraction despite revenue growth (margin compression signal); hyper_growth flag active but unsubstantiated by forward guidance; cyclical peak risk in 2024-2025 environment 1-3M
CONFIDENCE SCORE B 74 Data coverage adequate (10.66 P/E, 13.21 EPS confirmed); earnings date missing; forward guidance opaque; analyst dispersion moderate ($115–$198 range = 72% spread) 1-3M
Volatility & Drawdown Risk C+ 68 Beta 1.35x; 52-week range $117.50–$168.36 = 43% amplitude; intraday -3.08% on no news suggests elevated technical sensitivity; elevated crowding on 22.2% YTD return 1-3M
Crowding Risk Flag MODERATE 66 22.2% YTD return; 29 analyst coverage; recent Wells Fargo, UBS upgrades suggest momentum cascade; residential construction is consensus long-side trade into 2H2026 1-3M
PEER & SECTOR CONTEXT
Toll Brothers trades at a significant discount to luxury residential peers (P/E 10.66x vs. sector median ~14–16x) on a backdrop of housing demand anxiety and builder margin compression. The 3.62% revenue growth YoY is respectable but lags the broader US residential construction forecast (4.58% per WallStreetZen), signaling relative underperformance. The -1.97% EPS contraction despite rising topline indicates pricing power loss and/or cost inflation absorption. Beta 1.35x reflects cyclical sensitivity; the stock's 22.2% YTD rally has compressed valuations but invited crowding. Analyst consensus remains "Buy" with 29 coverage and a median target of $164.44 (9.4% upside), though the $115–$198 dispersion (72%) reveals genuine uncertainty about 2H2026 order trends and rate-sensitive demand.
TWO-HORIZON INSIGHT
Horizon Key Driver Base Case Risk
1–3 Months Near-term order flow, Q3 deliveries, margin guidance Consolidation in $148–$160 range; analyst upgrades offset macro caution; dividend yield (69bp) provides downside cushion Rising rates or consumer credit stress could trigger 8–12% pullback; crowding reversal on negative guidance
6–12 Months Housing affordability, rate environment, backlog conversion, new orders Earnings stabilization at 0–2% growth; P/E re-rating to 11.5–12.5x on improved visibility; target price $164–170 justified by dividend + modest growth Recession scenario (10% revenue decline, 30% EPS miss) could push stock to $100–110; luxury demand cliff if wealth effect wanes
FINAL VERDICT
HOLD / SELECTIVE BUY AT PULLBACK – Toll Brothers offers compelling "show-me" value (P/E 10.66x, 69bp yield) but faces near-term margin headwinds and EPS contraction despite revenue stability. The 22.2% YTD rally and crowded long positioning warrant patience for a 5–8% dip to $142–145 before accumulating; 12-month upside to analyst target $164.44 (9.4%) is adequate but not compelling given cyclical and macro risks.
WALL STREET ANALYST PRICE TARGET

Analyst Consensus: 16 analysts covering Toll Brothers have a consensus rating of "Buy" and an average price target of $164.44, forecasting a 29.82% increase in stock price over the next year . The lowest target is $115 and the highest is $198. At the current price of $150.20, this implies 9.4% upside to the consensus target, with a wide dispersion reflecting uncertainty on near-term housing demand and builder margins.

SNAPSHOT
Ticker
TOL
Company
Toll Brothers Inc
Sector / Industry
Consumer Products
Market Cap
$13.94B
Current Price
$148.53 -0.52%
52W Range
$123.15 – $168.36
52W Return
+11.97%
Dividend Yield
0.70% | $0.998/sh
EARNINGS MOMENTUM

Data Coverage Note: Earnings calendar and quarterly history unavailable. Analysis based on TTM metrics and forward guidance visibility.

Metric Value Assessment
EPS (TTM) $13.21 Current trailing earnings power
EPS Growth YoY -1.97% Declining — earnings compression YoY
Forward P/E 10.91x Implies ~$13.62 forward EPS (modest growth assumed)
Revenue Growth YoY +3.62% Soft — low single-digit top-line expansion
PEG Ratio -5.25 Negative EPS growth inverts PEG; valuation cannot be justified by growth alone
Earnings Momentum Score: 3.8/10
Earnings declined YoY despite modest 3.6% revenue growth, indicating margin compression or one-time charges. Forward guidance is weak. No near-term earnings acceleration visible.
PROFITABILITY & QUALITY

Data Constraint: Gross margin, operating margin, net margin, ROE, ROIC, and FCF are not disclosed in live data. Assessment based on available earnings and enterprise value metrics only.

Metric Value Inference
EPS $13.21 Positive earnings, but flat-to-declining YoY trend
P/E Ratio 10.35x Below market average; suggests either value positioning or earnings risk premium
Enterprise Value $13.94B Modest scale; limited operational leverage visibility
Revenue TTM Data Not Disclosed Unable to calculate turnover or return metrics
Profitability Flags Strong Profitability: FALSE System does not flag robust profit generation
Quality Score: 4.8/10
Limited visibility into margin structure and returns. Earnings quality appears soft given negative YoY growth despite revenue gains. Unable to confirm operational excellence without detailed P&L and balance sheet data.
BALANCE SHEET HEALTH

Data Constraint: Cash, total debt, equity, current ratio, and debt ratios are not available. Analysis limited to valuation-derived signals.

Metric Value Status
Cash Position Data Not Disclosed —
Total Debt Data Not Disclosed —
Net Debt/EBITDA Data Not Disclosed —
Interest Coverage Data Not Disclosed —
Balance Sheet Risk Flag Weak Balance: FALSE System does not flag distress; neutral signal only
Balance Sheet Risk: MODERATE
No explicit distress signals, but coverage constrained. Homebuilder sector typically carries elevated leverage for project financing. Cannot confirm liquidity or refinancing risk without debt structure detail.
VALUATION ANALYSIS
Metric Value Benchmark / Implication
Trailing P/E 10.35x Low absolute multiple; implies market discount or near-term headwinds
Forward P/E 10.91x Modest 5% premium to trailing; modest growth priced in
PEG Ratio -5.25 Invalid (negative growth); valuation multiple cannot be justified by earnings growth
Price / Sales Data Not Disclosed Revenue TTM unavailable; cannot assess revenue-based valuation
Price / FCF Data Not Disclosed FCF unavailable; cannot assess cash generation relative to price
EV/EBITDA Data Not Disclosed EBITDA not disclosed; limited sector comparison possible
52W Performance +11.97% Stock has rallied YTD but earnings declining; valuation expansion despite profit compression
Valuation Status: FAIRLY VALUED TO STRETCHED
P/E of 10.35x appears modest in absolute terms, but forward growth is weak and negative. Stock up 12% on the year while earnings down 2% — a divergence suggesting momentum-driven appreciation rather than fundamental improvement. Risk of valuation mean reversion if homebuilding cycle softens.
ANALYST TARGETS & SENTIMENT

Data Constraint: Consensus rating, target price, and earnings date not available. Wall Street sentiment assessment not possible.

Metric Value Implication
Consensus Rating Data Not Disclosed —
Average Target Price Data Not Disclosed —
Target Price Range Data Not Disclosed —
Implied Upside/Downside Data Not Disclosed —
Next Earnings Date Data Not Disclosed —
Wall Street Sentiment: UNKNOWN
Consensus research not available. Unable to assess analyst conviction, target dispersion, or near-term event risk. Recommend checking financial platforms for latest research reports and earnings calendar.
INSTITUTIONAL & RISK CHECK
Risk Factor Status Assessment
Institutional Ownership Trend Data Not Disclosed Unable to assess conviction or redemption risk
Insider Activity Data Not Disclosed No visibility into insider buy/sell signals
Short Interest Data Not Disclosed Unable to assess shorts or squeeze risk
Beta 1.298 ELEVATED — 30% more volatile than broad market; cyclical exposure
Sector Cyclicality Homebuilding Highly sensitive to interest rates, housing demand, credit conditions; macro tail risk elevated
Red Flags (System) High Valuation: FALSE
Hyper Growth: TRUE
Strong Profitability: FALSE
Weak Balance: FALSE
System flags "hyper growth" but this contradicts -1.97% YoY EPS; likely miscalibration. No profitability strength detected.
Risk Level: ELEVATED
Beta of 1.30 indicates significant volatility. Homebuilding is inherently cyclical and sensitive to Fed policy. Earnings decline into a rising-rate environment poses refinancing risk. Limited margin of safety given valuation and macro headwinds. Insider/institutional data unavailable, limiting conviction assessment.
FINAL ESEN VERDICT
Overall Fundamental Score
49
Below Average
Conviction Level
MODERATE-WEAK
Limited data transparency; high macro sensitivity; conflicting signals.
Short Term (1–3M)
HOLD / AVOID
Medium (6–12M)
NEUTRAL
Long Term (2Y+)
NEUTRAL
Summary — 5 Key Takeaways
  • ✓ Valuation Trap: P/E of 10.35x appears cheap but masks -1.97% YoY EPS decline and weak 3.6% revenue growth. Stock up 12% while earnings down—momentum-driven, not fundamental.
  • ✓ Cyclical Exposure: Beta of 1.30 and homebuilding sector sensitivity to rates/credit. Fed-induced cooling in housing demand poses downside tail risk. Near-term macro headwinds outweigh valuation discount.
  • ✓ Data Opacity: Revenue, profitability margins, balance sheet, FCF, and analyst consensus all unavailable. Cannot validate earnings quality or liquidity. Increases execution and refinancing risk assessment.
  • ✓ Dividend Safety: 0.70% yield on $0.998/sh is modest and supported by $13.21 EPS (76% payout coverage), but sustainability depends on earnings stabilization. No room for multiple compression + dividend cut.
  • ✓ Verdict: HOLD at best; consider AVOID until earnings stabilize and macro backdrop clears. Limited catalyst for near-term appreciation. Better risk/reward available in non-cyclical sectors or homebuilders with stronger margin profiles.

TOL Stock AI Analysis

ESEN AI analysis of TOL stock updated every 12 hours.

AI STOCK INSIGHT

TOL Stock Analysis & Forecast

Is TOL a Good Investment in 2026?

Our model indicates a neutral outlook based on current fundamentals and momentum.

TOL Stock Forecast

Based on recent earnings trends, valuation metrics, and sector performance, TOL shows balanced risk-reward characteristics.

Should You Buy TOL Now?

Investors should consider market conditions, volatility, and long-term positioning before taking a position in TOL.

Related Stocks
AAPL NVDA MSFT AMZN GOOGL META TSLA AVGO JPM V MA LLY UNH XOM JNJ WMT PG HD MRK COST BAC ABBV CRM CVX ORCL KO PEP AMD NFLX ADBE

Explore AI analysis for top stocks — Full Rankings · AI Screener · Earnings Calendar