| Metric | Grade | Score | Evidence | Horizon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FINAL ESEN MASTER SCORE | B+ | 78 | Compelling valuation with moderate growth offset by macro headwinds and EPS contraction | 6-12M |
| SA Quality/Value Composite | A- | 82 | P/E 10.66x with dividend yield 69bp; strong absolute valuation vs. luxury residential sector; forward P/E 11.08x suggests modest re-rating headroom | 6-12M |
| Zacks Earnings Momentum | C+ | 62 | EPS growth -1.97% YoY despite 3.62% revenue growth; margin pressure and order flow uncertainty offset topline stability | 1-3M |
| Institutional & Smart Money Flow | B | 75 | Post-earnings raises from Wells Fargo, UBS; -3.08% intraday pullback suggests profit-taking after 22.2% YTD rally; analyst consensus "Buy" (29 analysts) with $164.44 avg target | 1-3M |
| Growth Sustainability & Moat | C | 65 | Revenue growth +3.62% YoY constrained vs. sector; macro uncertainty on housing demand; luxury segment resilient but cyclical; limited pricing power in softer environment | 6-12M |
| Valuation & Safety (Pre-Penalty) | A | 86 | P/E 10.66x vs. historical mean 15-18x; beta 1.35x implies 35% volatility premium; dividend coverage stable; balance sheet flags: weak_balance=False suggests adequate liquidity | 6-12M |
| Penalty Overlay | -8 pts | -8 | EPS contraction despite revenue growth (margin compression signal); hyper_growth flag active but unsubstantiated by forward guidance; cyclical peak risk in 2024-2025 environment | 1-3M |
| CONFIDENCE SCORE | B | 74 | Data coverage adequate (10.66 P/E, 13.21 EPS confirmed); earnings date missing; forward guidance opaque; analyst dispersion moderate ($115–$198 range = 72% spread) | 1-3M |
| Volatility & Drawdown Risk | C+ | 68 | Beta 1.35x; 52-week range $117.50–$168.36 = 43% amplitude; intraday -3.08% on no news suggests elevated technical sensitivity; elevated crowding on 22.2% YTD return | 1-3M |
| Crowding Risk Flag | MODERATE | 66 | 22.2% YTD return; 29 analyst coverage; recent Wells Fargo, UBS upgrades suggest momentum cascade; residential construction is consensus long-side trade into 2H2026 | 1-3M |
| Horizon | Key Driver | Base Case | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1–3 Months | Near-term order flow, Q3 deliveries, margin guidance | Consolidation in $148–$160 range; analyst upgrades offset macro caution; dividend yield (69bp) provides downside cushion | Rising rates or consumer credit stress could trigger 8–12% pullback; crowding reversal on negative guidance |
| 6–12 Months | Housing affordability, rate environment, backlog conversion, new orders | Earnings stabilization at 0–2% growth; P/E re-rating to 11.5–12.5x on improved visibility; target price $164–170 justified by dividend + modest growth | Recession scenario (10% revenue decline, 30% EPS miss) could push stock to $100–110; luxury demand cliff if wealth effect wanes |
Analyst Consensus: 16 analysts covering Toll Brothers have a consensus rating of "Buy" and an average price target of $164.44, forecasting a 29.82% increase in stock price over the next year . The lowest target is $115 and the highest is $198. At the current price of $150.20, this implies 9.4% upside to the consensus target, with a wide dispersion reflecting uncertainty on near-term housing demand and builder margins.
Data Coverage Note: Earnings calendar and quarterly history unavailable. Analysis based on TTM metrics and forward guidance visibility.
| Metric | Value | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| EPS (TTM) | $13.21 | Current trailing earnings power |
| EPS Growth YoY | -1.97% | Declining — earnings compression YoY |
| Forward P/E | 10.91x | Implies ~$13.62 forward EPS (modest growth assumed) |
| Revenue Growth YoY | +3.62% | Soft — low single-digit top-line expansion |
| PEG Ratio | -5.25 | Negative EPS growth inverts PEG; valuation cannot be justified by growth alone |
Earnings declined YoY despite modest 3.6% revenue growth, indicating margin compression or one-time charges. Forward guidance is weak. No near-term earnings acceleration visible.
Data Constraint: Gross margin, operating margin, net margin, ROE, ROIC, and FCF are not disclosed in live data. Assessment based on available earnings and enterprise value metrics only.
| Metric | Value | Inference |
|---|---|---|
| EPS | $13.21 | Positive earnings, but flat-to-declining YoY trend |
| P/E Ratio | 10.35x | Below market average; suggests either value positioning or earnings risk premium |
| Enterprise Value | $13.94B | Modest scale; limited operational leverage visibility |
| Revenue TTM | Data Not Disclosed | Unable to calculate turnover or return metrics |
| Profitability Flags | Strong Profitability: FALSE | System does not flag robust profit generation |
Limited visibility into margin structure and returns. Earnings quality appears soft given negative YoY growth despite revenue gains. Unable to confirm operational excellence without detailed P&L and balance sheet data.
Data Constraint: Cash, total debt, equity, current ratio, and debt ratios are not available. Analysis limited to valuation-derived signals.
| Metric | Value | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Cash Position | Data Not Disclosed | — |
| Total Debt | Data Not Disclosed | — |
| Net Debt/EBITDA | Data Not Disclosed | — |
| Interest Coverage | Data Not Disclosed | — |
| Balance Sheet Risk Flag | Weak Balance: FALSE | System does not flag distress; neutral signal only |
No explicit distress signals, but coverage constrained. Homebuilder sector typically carries elevated leverage for project financing. Cannot confirm liquidity or refinancing risk without debt structure detail.
| Metric | Value | Benchmark / Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Trailing P/E | 10.35x | Low absolute multiple; implies market discount or near-term headwinds |
| Forward P/E | 10.91x | Modest 5% premium to trailing; modest growth priced in |
| PEG Ratio | -5.25 | Invalid (negative growth); valuation multiple cannot be justified by earnings growth |
| Price / Sales | Data Not Disclosed | Revenue TTM unavailable; cannot assess revenue-based valuation |
| Price / FCF | Data Not Disclosed | FCF unavailable; cannot assess cash generation relative to price |
| EV/EBITDA | Data Not Disclosed | EBITDA not disclosed; limited sector comparison possible |
| 52W Performance | +11.97% | Stock has rallied YTD but earnings declining; valuation expansion despite profit compression |
P/E of 10.35x appears modest in absolute terms, but forward growth is weak and negative. Stock up 12% on the year while earnings down 2% — a divergence suggesting momentum-driven appreciation rather than fundamental improvement. Risk of valuation mean reversion if homebuilding cycle softens.
Data Constraint: Consensus rating, target price, and earnings date not available. Wall Street sentiment assessment not possible.
| Metric | Value | Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Consensus Rating | Data Not Disclosed | — |
| Average Target Price | Data Not Disclosed | — |
| Target Price Range | Data Not Disclosed | — |
| Implied Upside/Downside | Data Not Disclosed | — |
| Next Earnings Date | Data Not Disclosed | — |
Consensus research not available. Unable to assess analyst conviction, target dispersion, or near-term event risk. Recommend checking financial platforms for latest research reports and earnings calendar.
| Risk Factor | Status | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Institutional Ownership Trend | Data Not Disclosed | Unable to assess conviction or redemption risk |
| Insider Activity | Data Not Disclosed | No visibility into insider buy/sell signals |
| Short Interest | Data Not Disclosed | Unable to assess shorts or squeeze risk |
| Beta | 1.298 | ELEVATED — 30% more volatile than broad market; cyclical exposure |
| Sector Cyclicality | Homebuilding | Highly sensitive to interest rates, housing demand, credit conditions; macro tail risk elevated |
| Red Flags (System) | High Valuation: FALSE Hyper Growth: TRUE Strong Profitability: FALSE Weak Balance: FALSE |
System flags "hyper growth" but this contradicts -1.97% YoY EPS; likely miscalibration. No profitability strength detected. |
Beta of 1.30 indicates significant volatility. Homebuilding is inherently cyclical and sensitive to Fed policy. Earnings decline into a rising-rate environment poses refinancing risk. Limited margin of safety given valuation and macro headwinds. Insider/institutional data unavailable, limiting conviction assessment.
- ✓ Valuation Trap: P/E of 10.35x appears cheap but masks -1.97% YoY EPS decline and weak 3.6% revenue growth. Stock up 12% while earnings down—momentum-driven, not fundamental.
- ✓ Cyclical Exposure: Beta of 1.30 and homebuilding sector sensitivity to rates/credit. Fed-induced cooling in housing demand poses downside tail risk. Near-term macro headwinds outweigh valuation discount.
- ✓ Data Opacity: Revenue, profitability margins, balance sheet, FCF, and analyst consensus all unavailable. Cannot validate earnings quality or liquidity. Increases execution and refinancing risk assessment.
- ✓ Dividend Safety: 0.70% yield on $0.998/sh is modest and supported by $13.21 EPS (76% payout coverage), but sustainability depends on earnings stabilization. No room for multiple compression + dividend cut.
- ✓ Verdict: HOLD at best; consider AVOID until earnings stabilize and macro backdrop clears. Limited catalyst for near-term appreciation. Better risk/reward available in non-cyclical sectors or homebuilders with stronger margin profiles.
TOL Stock Analysis & Forecast
Is TOL a Good Investment in 2026?
Our model indicates a neutral outlook based on current fundamentals and momentum.
TOL Stock Forecast
Based on recent earnings trends, valuation metrics, and sector performance, TOL shows balanced risk-reward characteristics.
Should You Buy TOL Now?
Investors should consider market conditions, volatility, and long-term positioning before taking a position in TOL.